A statement is followed by two Assumptions numbered I and II. Consider the Statement and Assumptions and decide which of the given Assumptions is/are implicit in the Statement ?
Statement : Retired persons should not be appointed for executive posts in other organisations.
Assumptions : I. Retired persons may lack the zeal and commitment to carry out executive's work.
II. Retired persons do not take interest in the work and welfare of the new organisation.
CBSE Assistant Secretary - 2024,
Answer: D
The key gives neither Assumption I nor II is implicit.
An assumption is implicit only if the statement would make no sense without it. The statement is a plain prohibition: retired persons should not be appointed to executive posts in other organisations. It gives no reason, so any reason a reader supplies is a guess about the writer's thinking, not something the sentence needs to take for granted.
Assumption I (retired persons may lack zeal and commitment) is one possible reason, but the same advice could rest on age, on keeping posts open for younger people or on possible conflicts of interest. Assumption II goes further and says that retired persons do not take interest in the work and welfare of the new organisation, a sweeping claim the statement does not need. Neither is required, so neither is implicit.
A reader could argue that Assumption I is the most natural reason and so is implied; the key takes the stricter reading, and this explanation follows the key.
Please log in or register to report this question.