Machine-translated by Google. Questions are authored in English.
Top

Discussion

Which one of the following gives the strongest evidence that the moon is derived from the earth.

  • A.Proximity of the moon to the earth
  • B.Both the moon and earth have basaltic crust
  • C.Both have similar oxygen isotopic composition
  • D.Silicate-earth and silicate-moon have similar SiO\(_{2}\) and MgO content

Answer: C

The strongest evidence is that both have similar oxygen isotopic composition.

Different bodies of the solar system, such as Mars and the parent bodies of meteorites, have distinct ratios of the three oxygen isotopes, like a fingerprint. Lunar rocks lie on the same mass-fractionation line as terrestrial rocks, which shows that the Moon formed from material of the same reservoir as the Earth, as the giant-impact hypothesis requires.

Proximity says nothing about origin, since a captured body could be close too. Basaltic crusts are found on many rocky bodies, and the bulk SiO\(_{2}\) and MgO of the silicate Moon and Earth are only broadly alike, so these are much weaker evidence.

No comment is present. Be the first to comment.
Loading…

Post your comment

Please log in or register to post a comment.