Machine-translated by Google. Questions are authored in English.
Top

Discussion

Rb-Sr age based on the individual minerals often yield younger age than that of the whole rock age. The reason for this is :

  • A.The whole rock gives enough sample to date the rock accurately
  • B.The whole rock contains more \(^{87}\)Kb than the individual minerals
  • C.Individual minerals have a higher closure temperature and diffusion of Sr atoms is not random at smaller scale (~ a few meters)
  • D.Individual minerals have a lower closure temperature and diffusion of Sr atoms is random at smaller (~ a few meters) scale

Answer: D

The reason given by the key is that individual minerals have a lower closure temperature and Sr diffusion is random at the smaller scale.

After a rock forms, a later heating event can make radiogenic \(^{87}\)Sr move out of Rb-rich minerals such as biotite into neighbouring minerals. The individual minerals close to Sr diffusion at relatively low temperatures, so their clocks are reset and record the later event, giving a younger age. But the Sr only moves over short distances, so a whole-rock sample of adequate size remains a closed system and still records the original age.

The option claiming a higher closure temperature for minerals reverses the cause. The size of the sample does not by itself change an age, and '87Kb' (for \(^{87}\)Rb) content explains nothing about the age difference.

No comment is present. Be the first to comment.
Loading…

Post your comment

Please log in or register to post a comment.