Machine-translated by Google. Questions are authored in English.
Top

Discussion

Lawrence Kohlberg's theory has been critiqued by Carol Gilligan for :

  • A.ignoring gender differences in moral reasoning.
  • B.not applying quantitative methods of analysis.
  • C.presenting a stage-theory of moral development.
  • D.collecting data by means of real-life situations.

Answer: A

Carol Gilligan criticised Kohlberg for ignoring gender differences in moral reasoning.

Kohlberg built his stages largely from interviews with boys and scored moral reasoning by an ethic of justice and rights. In In a Different Voice (1982) Gilligan argued that this made women's typical reasoning, an ethic of care and responsibility in relationships, look less developed, and that the theory was therefore biased.

Kohlberg did present a stage theory, but that was not Gilligan's objection. Her critique was not about quantitative methods, and his data came from hypothetical dilemmas such as Heinz's, not real-life situations; Gilligan herself used real-life dilemmas.

No comment is present. Be the first to comment.
Loading…

Post your comment

Please log in or register to post a comment.