Machine-translated by Google. Questions are authored in English.
Top

Discussion

Which of the following statements is not true in the context of the transformation of a response variable under a regression set-up ?

  • A.When E(Y) = V(Y) = C (a constant), square root transformation is more appropriate
  • B.When E(Y) = C and \(V(Y) = C^{2}\), log transformation is more appropriate
  • C.Scale transformation preserve the directions of the association between Y and X
  • D.The Box-Cox transformation \(Y \to g(Y, \lambda)\) is a discontinuous function of \(\lambda\)

Answer: D

The statement that is not true is The Box-Cox transformation is a discontinuous function of \(\lambda\).

The Box-Cox transformation is \(g(Y, \lambda) = (Y^{\lambda} - 1)/\lambda\) for \(\lambda \ne 0\) and \(\log Y\) for \(\lambda = 0\). The \(-1\) and the division by \(\lambda\) are there precisely to make it continuous in \(\lambda\): as \(\lambda \to 0\), \((Y^{\lambda} - 1)/\lambda \to \log Y\).

The other statements are the standard variance-stabilising rules. When the variance equals the mean (Poisson-like data), \(\sqrt{Y}\) stabilises it (A). When the standard deviation is proportional to the mean, \(\log Y\) does (B). And a positive change of scale does not change the sign of the association (C).

No comment is present. Be the first to comment.
Loading…

Post your comment

Please log in or register to post a comment.