Machine-translated by Google. Questions are authored in English.
Top

Discussion

Let \((X_{1}, X_{2}) \sim N_{2}(\mu, \Sigma)\) where \(\Sigma\) is a +ve definite matrix. Then which of the following has a singular normal distribution where \(X_{3} = X_{1} - 2X_{2}\) ?

  • A.\(X_{1} + X_{3}, X_{1} - X_{2}\)
  • B.\(X_{1} - X_{3}, X_{2} - X_{3}\)
  • C.\(X_{1}, X_{3}\)
  • D.\(X_{2}, X_{3}\)

Answer: A

The singular pair is \(X_{1} + X_{3},\ X_{1} - X_{2}\).

With \(X_{3} = X_{1} - 2X_{2}\):

\[ X_{1} + X_{3} = 2X_{1} - 2X_{2} = 2(X_{1} - X_{2}) \]

so the two components of option A are exact multiples of each other. Their joint normal distribution lives on a line, and its covariance matrix has rank 1: it is singular.

The others are non-singular linear transforms of \((X_{1}, X_{2})\), whose covariance \(\Sigma\) is positive definite: \((X_{1} - X_{3}, X_{2} - X_{3}) = (2X_{2}, 3X_{2} - X_{1})\), \((X_{1}, X_{3})\) and \((X_{2}, X_{3})\) each come from a \(2 \times 2\) matrix with non-zero determinant.

No comment is present. Be the first to comment.
Loading…

Post your comment

Please log in or register to post a comment.