Machine-translated by Google. Questions are authored in English.
Top

Discussion

If 'No S is P' is a false statement, then which of these statements is necessarily true ?

  • A.All S is P
  • B.Some S is P
  • C.Some S is not P
  • D.None of the above

Answer: B

If 'No S is P' is false, then Some S is P is necessarily true.

In traditional logic, 'No S is P' (a universal negative, E) and 'Some S is P' (a particular affirmative, I) are contradictories: exactly one of them is true. So when 'No S is P' is false, 'Some S is P' must be true.

'All S is P' may or may not be true: it is possible that only some S are P. 'Some S is not P' is also undetermined, since every S might be P. Only 'Some S is P' follows necessarily, so 'None of the above' is wrong too.

No comment is present. Be the first to comment.
Loading…

Post your comment

Please log in or register to post a comment.