Rajasthan High Court Civil Judge 2017: Civil Judge Cadre, Main Examination, Law Paper II
Text of page 1
TotalPages-48 CODE NO.
Notto be filed by rhe candidate
oqafl E:RI Tff T{r qri
Time :3 Hours
Maximum Marks: 1OO
rreAi 6"qo, tM poRTANT tNSTRUcTtoNS
1. sdfud frfi"r ltdfr 'cEr qr-sE-iriN
ctudr o 6q{ F{d lr{ qdc cr A ftrd. qq fars Rrrr qr
2 qE{ q,-v6-sm stu6r- n" *+ a-,* J ,_* ;;; 'HHL:f_' rfi +
l
qqr/tdqiq:r,*. t+oni a qr< oeri o'r
"eor
6 *. t
___. irq. {dT. ffid
"".O. _tg,i';'#.#*"1* RT+ * rfto *t
, +H Im H tTi# :[ y " -- * ".*+ a *e+ +# r r,,q# rq< 6? a q*n
* *,i a "+-'Jeo ffi"H'#*LroHi#,ffi#
r
ad irEso 6rffi tg .i srr<ra crir Brirr I
a. qp.if si q@r 3itr vrd ii6 -q.{i qr_q6_rfl gkoi i 3,.f6-d
*,X,fr m*
ftrn id ti
t cFd + s.r{ fr-srflq rc t !.ar rr_FE + r*o qrt a iq ,i4 ,rd *rr ql A tu.
vq2n N Tfl 6 tr ttr+ trrrT -rfi T
q;{r ry6T. 6S 3th rfl.
s er,sfi srr filrlft-d 1e-tFr
v.rE i ff tui ftd,n cRfuh t
"lrajn,
f{6 nfir gtu6r r-S a or&fr
d q'q{' 6 qffi i qrsr Rr+ qerdr'3i+6 ti * #* #"
I
*I;ts-d1 ,- I}ft-d 6l dpn sfl vs
o. hii+-qvr n crr-f d td qE-if, .i oE r<-r .n rl,r* lr|tr=I Ft qErar+ fir .nr{
e zfq qrl qr-{d-ifi{ sth+r 6fi rt da_6ad qt irghd e + .m#" +rq'.- j _J 6-r sd {.d-sr d qr 416 d
I
qr i dr i, sqrn Es6t Erfu€ irqrff or Elm
10 qollr oql q fr t {t ]r{rr + dqriho ri{,
+ sllr ra{ oirr qden sli{d tl
1' wrire rhe required particurars oniv on the frap provided on
the top of "Qu€stion paper-cum Answer sook-;
any other place. and not at
2 Do not writ€ any mark of identiry inside the .
Ro No . Name, address. M.,,;',;;;,;;;;l:i,'::1,:fi:;:T.
of qlestion. such act wil be keated as unfa r
J.J:::ff[Jlll]"1lT,li11ll1ll1,",i,llll.l1
meens. h such a .ase his candidature sha
oGmrnatioh be rejected for the entire
3 A candidate found cre.ting dkrurbance at th
w, render hm,,.u" r.,00q""r,"",,." ;"TI":*";IH:.J;.::::|,::,:I#:1,11T;:,:ffT,Jl;
Examination (preve.tion of UnfairMeans)
Act, 1992.
'a The number of q uestions and thei. marks are indicated
tn the
"euestion paper cum,Answer
5. Ihe answers of the questions shotltd stricly be.written in the Boor.
space prwid* 1r." .i"*" _, ,****,
otherwise, such answer shal not be assessed
bythe examin€r. -"
6. The candidate shoutd write the answ€rs in the provided
space' No supplementary Answer Book
anycase. sharr be provided in
z Specifv.n option of language Hindior English, by tickin8,/ in bor
of"M€dtrrm cf Answe/, on the flap and answer
the same opted tanSuage. in
s rn anv question' ifthere h anv discrepanc'v
in Entrish &
s In case the,,euestion paper-cum-answer Book" istorn Hindiversions, the EnSrish version is to b€ treated as st.ndard.
or not printed prop;,0.,", n i" *,.,n.
chanSe or dte.tion, ar ea diest orheeise
l0
the candi.rates wifl be tiabte for that. ",,r,r*,".r.,
Possession ofanvtvpe oferectronic
device isstrictrv prohibited ar the Examination
Har.
JS-LP IT,17
t
Text of page 3
Question No.4 [o3 Marksl [l
Summarize, the "Power of a Judge" under section 165 Evidence Act
qlrl {isr 4
rrres sriDftqq ai qm ros t sFtir "arruEff{r d Yri&r" oj *id,I t {dr{d t
question No.5 [03 Marks]
'Hari', prosecutes'Kalu' for adultery with his wife 'Neelu"Kalu'
denies that'Neelu'is wife of'Hari'. The Court convicts'Kalu'for the
adultery. Afterwards, 'Neelu' is prosecuted for bigamy in marrying
'Kalu' during 'Hari's' lifetime. 'Neelu' says that she never married to
'Hari'. 'Hari' produced copy of judgment, wherein, 'Kalu' was convicted
for adultery with 'Neelu'.
Whether, judgment in case of 'Kalu' is relevant against'Neelu'?
Explain in brief with relevant provision.
q{.I {IGII 5
'r0'. 'orS ol rqff r"i 'fl( d wr vnm \ otrr<ifto orat tt
'oicl {{ srd d a6R 6{irr i i6 +{. 'Efl' ol qFff lr anqrmq 6rE 6\
qrfir tE dsR'[d 6{ tm Bt (crdTd. 'Eff'd fr+rora nt6rE li EftslE
6{i AS '+( oi s{Frdkd fa-qr qrm t t ttr( r<ff t f} itfli s.fi 6ff' t
laqra cfi fuqrr 'aQ' ss ffq ol qld tyr 6{dr t firs{ fu tl{ 6}:ftq d
rnr urror tg ffi< f6-lr {qt an t
qqr. .6'r{ d Esg qrltc h.fq '-{r{ d la5d {{i'r.l t ? g{i'rd
crqsrrr r1Fd igq q w€ olfirt t
Question No.6 [03 Marks]
'A', just for enjoyment and fun with labours working in his field,
drives a tractor around them in rash and negligent manner. Next day
he repeats the same act in same mood and manner. A labour 8et hit
by the tractor and resultantly, dies.
Whether,'A'has committed any offence on both the days?
Explain with brief reasons.
q9'r {t 14. 6
'A', sqi dd il od znc {i {f,Wl t {iilro-qi-{w{ t( dd f gcd
3Trs qRr istnl q ddr{etrn d }.tr aarot t r srrd l}< "ff a< ii€ Xs a affi
t a-fi qcq d6nrr B r 16 qw(r is,c{ t ro{l qrct i s cR"nr.i wrutl *f.g
d .rr,i t t
qqr. 'A' i a-ri ft-{{n Ei iFig 3Ttr{tt fu-fl i z r4l*w onqi {Fid qcE
+1f="rit r
Text of page 4
question No.7 [03 Marks]
'Madan'married'Geeta'as per Hindu rites and ceremonies in
year 2001. Just after 9 months of marriage, they began to live
separately in different towns due to rift. After 7 years, 'Geeta' married
with an unmarried person 'Suresh', after disclosing all the facts to him.
'Madan', after knowing about the marriage of 'Geeta', also get
married with a legally divorcee Hindu lady 'Babita', concealing the
facts about his previous marriage.
State with brief reasons regarding criminal liability (if any) of
Madan, Geeta, Suresh and Babita.
qg'I {l19II 7
Tfi 6r E{ 2001 il rftdr € Rq ffi-ffit i ft-orr g:n r fu<n d
qlJ e qr6 qraE d s{rqfi crr*q d 6pq 4;1 \r{' ESt * Gr.rrr.
{gi o.'€l n
wi at t z syl caqrd rfl-dr i \.6 3rffiad qffi Tlt{r' o) uE n2s {dri Eg.
Bsn fil4r6 d{ fiql I rt-dr d ft-qr6 arr rrdr rf,i q{ T{{ i .ff \'4r aq sc d
ildr6g{I kq d qRdr' .li. ur"i Td fd-4rd d f,ld o) ffi gr, l?<r< ov
ftqrr
Tfi. ftdr, gt{r gd 4Edr d qrqtrfuo <rfua (qE ot{ di) +) {iftR
anq *,ftc corsi t
Question No.8 [03 Marks]
What is the definition of "Sexual Harassment", under the
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012.
q{;I d@r I
dFr6 3rwqt Q er 61 6r *irerq eiEftqq, zorz, d err+lo "dFr+
sm.s{" +1 tffi cRqrsl t z
Question No.9 [03 Marks]
'X', renowned builder in ordinary course of his business agreed
to sale one flat to'Y'. As'Y'belongs to Schedule Caste, so next day he
denies to sell, stating to 'Y'that, this would adversely affect the sale of
remaining flats.
Whether,'X'has committed any offence under The Schedule
Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989?
Support the answer with the provisions of relevant law.
!IYjI U&rlI I
'X', 3rci qffirq d {{rql{ 3f,16q fr 'Y' o) q6 rfu H d
sdq6
E3nI qfr Y 3rlgfud srid or qlm t, sm, ir.d Ft{ T6 {s r<i gq ft-l;.q $
r-{r E{ tdr e fo. g$S ts c*c€ 61 ffirft-q sv ri Eni{d dff I
Text of page 5
c{r. 'X' cRr c1qfud "Tft silt er5qfoa s.rffi (ertotqR ftan"r)
3rBffiq, rgsg d 3r;.flifl 6ig or,.Rrq flqr rur t ? Iqrrd frfi' d crqunt qfta
s-.rq qqQlo dfud t
Question No.10 [03 Marks]
"Abhishek", a member of schedule tribes abuses a lady
"Kamali", a member of scheduled caste, by saying "Chamari", at the
bus stand.
What offence has been committed by "Abhishek" under The
Schedule Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act,
1989. Briefly discuss with reasons.
q{i q_ai{ll 10
3ri{':kr "ii"rfi or {r({s "3{FftF' rlqtnc .atli o1 ,tf}at "ord'
g arl ri,.,i '4rir0" 66 rx .n.fl .rdiq orrtr i t
'r{
erlqfi6 "111; ck rlrf+o s{srfr (3riqFrR ft<lq"r) orftfiql. rsss d
qrdETrii d 3m-id. ghlt6" Er{t arr errw fu:n ,r:rr *? 6n"t .{Ttrd EHc t
iiiFlo .rjll--r?) t
Question No.l1 [on Marks] f]
'A', filed a complaint before a Magistrate against'B'for house
trespass. During inquiry made by Court under section 202 of Cr.P.C.,
'A' produced and examined 'C' as his witness. Afterwards, due to
death of'C' he could not be examined during the trial.
Whether, statement of'C', recorded during inquiry is relevant
as previous statement and can be used against'B'in the trail? Explain
in brief with reasons.
gY;I lI{e{I l1
'A' i 'B' ri ft"r"< .|6 erfuan 6ii iE qf$dz d rrqei [o cR-drE
rqa fu-at | ;{I{IIaTq dRr r.[r] 202 E.c.€. d orB,fd 01 ,r{ c,fis d +{r-r 'A' i
'c' sl 3{ci sEff A sq I t{ or ctllfd 6{qrqr I dsrard 'c'd Iq d riri
d arsq si fadR"r d dtrn qtka +€t osqrqr qt {fl t
zqr. qiq d ftr{ is{d 'C' d i6fi. qffi oen d w i g+i.m t
Fi 'B' d ft-sa fr-*nu n rgm flt qr {r6d d? 6Rq qlad {*q i rc€
offit
Question No.12 [04 Marks]
What are the salient features of the offence "Giving false
evidence" and "Fabricating false evidence". Explain in brief.
Text of page 6
Yr.t {lql 12
3rq{F.1. "l}Q.qr {flerT eru" f4 "fiu,n {lTeq ,tc.tr". d,1 qgq licl,idr\ +fl
B ? nerc i se dtffi
Question No.13 [04 Marksl
Explain in short, the definition of "Domestic Violence" under
the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.
g{.I g{qII 13
qt{ fE{fl t qEarcri or ,.i**r ffii{w, zoos d oi'f,dn "qlq fiflr"
o1 qfurw +i qrdrq d rqsl.d
Question No.14 [04 Marksl
Write a short note on the provisions of Bail with regard to
offence relating to commercial quantity of contraband, under Narcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985
tJc.t ti{ertt tl
rqro :twft G qr sqA q(rd Dfiq,r, rsas .l qMd fiB< ,rd a1
ffitGqo qr* ti 3r.r{tr d rrEaT rl Grlld q) yr.ErFJ w fiEq fdqoff fift+q r
Question No.15 [04 Marks]
Whether, is it mandatory for iuvenile lustice Board to release
the child-in-conflict with law on bail, alleged to have committed an
offence? When and for which offences bail can be denied, explain
rationally.
SY'I TI{4IT 15
qqr. lBrfr .orq drd i( \.6 faftI t #ro <roo. ffi cRr 3I[{u
l+-qr snr a{Mfd fuqr .rqT B +J qqFm qs R-a orrr eroqo i ? oq q
fu-{ 3rq{Fn i{
qqmd C a6n ftrfi qr sorr t. trd'-*i.rr w rl ftifu'r
dml
Question No.15 los Marksl
Discuss the provisions relating to recording of statement of a
child by Police and a Magistrate, under Protection of Children from
Sexual Offences Act, 2012.
IJ{{ {I@I 16
gfi*l rd qftrie errT d6 d 6er;r As.r€ d{i d +<.t {. iiFr6
qqqrtii r] *oro'i or clqer"r erl*fi.rq. zorz. ,] q[n1o ql.ut.t) ol f:tifio dfird t
Question No.17 [05 Marksl
lvlake a comparative discussion in brief, w th regard to mode of
rccording of evidence and power to award sentence in sLrmmary trial
JS LP II ]7
Text of page 8
Question No.20 [08 Marks]
What is "Dowry Death"? Explain the presumption provided
under section 113-8 of Evidence Act. When it can be invoked and what
is it's effect on burden of proof.
u t.t {Ir<II 20
'qis fq" rqr I ? trnr i13-q srs 3rfuftqq { spfd gqqRsl 6)
we oi t gfr oq anl fu-qr qr root t gq qrR-d ta.{i d "m w $sor '+qr
cqmt?
Question No.21 [10 Marks]
'R' is charged for voluntarily causing grievous hurt by using acid
on 'Sunita'. During the trial following facts are established;
1. About 15 days prior to the incident, while'Sunita' was going to college
along with her friend'5uman', 'R' proposed'sunita'to marry but she
vehemently denied, as she was going to be marry with another
person.'R' threatened her.
2. On fateful day of incident, while 'Sunita' was going to market alon8
with her friend 'suman', a biker threw acid on her and fleed away.
3. Oral testimony as well as medical opinion reveals that 'Sunita'
received injuries of facial disfiguration by the use of acid. No injury
sign was found on the body of'R'.
4. Except'Sunita'and'Suman', the other eye-witnesses did not support
prosecution case.
5, A bottle with residuary of acid was recovered from the room of'R'.
Write a reasoned judgment, keeping in mind the aspect of
Compensation also.
U?.1 tlteql 21
'R'd, {+dr d gfu<; rm +rsqr rfft sc-aftqi 6rftd o$ aq 3iltRd
fuqr rrqT + | ftqxq d ?tqn ffifo6 6qa renftd gq d
'
r. rrn t rs ier gd. q{ !ffdr 3ItrA sM Tq+' d qrq oiis w {ff f ii{
'R' i T{rdl c} Eara or qwr4 {r4r, rrg gfi-cr 'i grciir d.r $ a6R tuqr,
Tdfu yftq A '$+dr' 01 ffar€ fiffi 3lh d {rs, d.i ardr an I 'R' A s{i q'{fil
At
z. ttE<r d 3sE fi{. qE t.ffdr 3{Tff trt"ft jn<' d srq ersR qt tfi ,i. \.6
Wf6a qrao i ss w \ft-e *fir 3fq qFT rrqr l
s. dfuo qlq d rflp-r-fler frl?,eftq qrq t fi qr roz dff i fu rJfrdr d &
d fi{fts{q ol srdfr \'k€ t 6rRd gi I I 'R' d yr0{ qt ol$ q}e d fffiq
rS qri .ri r
+. t1frrn' a ET{' d fu-4rq, 3rq iid fi aqa$ enff i erMr+ 66rff ot
mef+ rfi fuqr t
s. 'R'd oqt g6 {ttrd. (t€ d sr4Rre ql6d a*rr< at ,r{ r
t
Text of page 9
qfn'{,{ d qdil +t dl urr.r d rui gr. ro aj,{ir1d fuq l}foi 1
Question No.22 U0 Marksl
Write a judgment on following facts:
A lady'Meena'was waiting for a bus near Pali Railway Station.
A boy, around 20 years age came on the motorcycle, snatched
'Meena's'gold chain of 50 gms and escaped before that lady could see
his face. Shc lodged a report in the Policc Station. On the next day,
'Ram Singh', aged about 21 years was arrested by police in connection
with a similar offence. He gave information to the police, that the day
before, he had snatched gold chain of a woman and sold it to a
jeweler. He showed that shop to police. Police seized gold chain of 50
gms. and sale receipt. 'Meena' identified the gold chain. Police did
further investigation and filed charge-sheet against'Ram Singh'.
'Ram Singh' denied everything in his statement u/s 313 Cr.P.C.
and alleged that police has falsely implicated him and forcibly taken
his statement, while he was in their custody.
q l.l {lt4lJ 22
go qftifl 'ff.{r. crs H € rl 4} qm {fl or r.rqrq or rS fr t
6flrrl 20 q{ o1 sng or \.6 s{r Nft-d q{ snqr 3ik {sd c-rd fo
ri-cr ss+r A-flr is qrff, ar -,rsibl so .rrq 01 Hri dt i.l 6i sqe 6r
"n-r
.lqr I ,rri gft'r{ afii t w R+C (d 6€r{ I 3rd ft{. gfds i t+qr< iqq{Itt
e gg qrrA i r.r fH<'.3rrg drrqrT zr s{. ol Fr{Fn fu''qr r ssi gfkrt 6)
g+tt d i6, v6 fur q.d rri 95 q66 61 *n d +r s[a pn, Er* rsi
das o) tqr t I ssi Td son gfuir oi fteri r Sfus i drr t so nr {{ii
sl itr 3ilr frrq wfts oi s< fb-q-r | 'q{r'i {iii o1 i.r dl ftrrR< or ft{rr
yf{fl i 3rFnfl srjqurr or \rq Ri6' d Fiq"q s{rtq tr, rkJa f}qr t
Trq fifE 3rci 313 EuG qft-qr qEor d oqci ti Trq ffi d fon l6qr a
i
3IFr6Ero fu-qr ft, gftrs sS fre4r +iiAF B,c'r d 3i-{ w tre s+d orn-{eTr i
pn na vsd orr-r sq.{dl trri r} lOfficial key not published for this paper.
Page 1 of 9
Source: Rajasthan High Court. Question paper published by Rajasthan High Court.