Machine-translated by Google. Questions are authored in English.
Top

Historical Method and Historiography Questions and Answers

Direction for [ Question No: 71 To 74 ] :

Read the following passage carefully and choose the correct answer of the questions that follow :

Causation is a concept of such fundamental importance to historical understanding that E.H. Carr in his G.M. Trevelyan lectures (1961) declared the study of history to be the study of causes. But postmodernist thinking on the issue of historical causation is different. John Vincent would abandon the search for causes as futile and rather look for explanations. Writing in 1976, Theodore Zeldin thought of causation and chronology as the two tyrants to historians. Hayden White attacked the concept of causation as depriving people of both their freedom of action in the present and of control over the future by trapping them in an inescapable network of causation. Postmodernist theory installs interpretation in the place of empirical research into the causes of specific events. Since the notion of cause depends on sequential time, some postmodernists attack the latter too. The cause of an occurrence must obviously come before it in time. But the postmodernist historian and philosopher, Ankersmit, says "Historical time is a recent and highly artificial invention of Western civilization," and the writing of historical narrative based on the concept of time, he has declared, is "building on quicksand." The postmodernists would prefer that the idea of sequential time be abandoned in the writing of history. Richard Evans shows how the very idea of postmodern is paradoxical in that it is contrary to the assertion that there are no time periods in history. And the postmodernist statement that historical time is a thing of the past, itself uses the historical concept of time which the statement is intended to dismiss. The linear and sequential concept of time is far too powerful a principle to be dispensed with, for it is not an intellectual construct but a matter of everyday experience for people the world over. Time itself may be without boundaries, but in terms of human life it passes, and has limits.

Answer: D

The passage opens by saying that postmodernist thinking on historical causation is different from Carr's view, and then reports several positions: Vincent would give up the search for causes as futile, Zeldin called causation and chronology tyrants, White said causation traps people in a network, and the theory puts interpretation in place of research into causes. Option D, that there are different opinions, is the official key because it covers all of these. Options A, B and C each describe only one postmodernist's view, and C is also supported by the passage, but D is the broadest.

Please log in or register to report this question.

Answer: D

The passage says postmodernists attack the concept of sequential time, call historical time a Western invention and would prefer to abandon the idea. It is therefore wrong to say that the factor of time has not been thought of by intellectuals, because the passage names Ankersmit and others who have thought about it carefully. That statement, option D, is not the postmodernist concept of time. Options A, B and C can be taken as consistent with the views reported in the passage.

Please log in or register to report this question.

73.

Who amongst the following wrote that the cause-effect relationship is an obstacle for History ?

Exam Year(s)

UGC NET - 2012,

Answer: D

Theodore Zeldin, writing in 1976, thought of causation and chronology as the two tyrants to historians, which matches the idea of the cause-effect relationship as an obstacle. Hayden White also attacked causation, but he is not among the options. Richard Evans in the passage is the one who points out the paradox in postmodernism, Ankersmit attacks historical time and E.H. Carr treats the study of history as the study of causes. The answer is Theodore Zeldin, option D.

Please log in or register to report this question.

74.

Which one of the following said that the narrative History writing considering the Time is like constructing a building on a weak foundation ?

Exam Year(s)

UGC NET - 2012,

Answer: A

Ankersmit said that historical time is a recent and highly artificial invention of Western civilization and described historical narrative built on the concept of time as building on quicksand, that is, on a weak foundation. Theodore Zeldin spoke of the two tyrants of causation and chronology, Richard Evans criticised the postmodernist position, and E.H. Carr argued for the study of causes. The answer is Ankersmit, option A.

Please log in or register to report this question.

75.

Match List - I (Authors) with List - II (Books) and select the correct answer from the codes given below :

List - IList - II
a. Lucien Febvre1. The Peasants of the Languedoc
b. Max Bloch2. The Historian's Craft
c. Emmanuel L.R. Ladurie3. The Mediterranean
d. Fernand Braudel4. The Regions of France : Franche Comte

Codes : a b c d

Exam Year(s)

UGC NET - 2013,

Answer: C

The match is a-4, b-2, c-1, d-3.

Lucien Febvre wrote a regional study of Franche-Comte, The Regions of France (4). Marc Bloch wrote The Historian's Craft (2). Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie wrote The Peasants of Languedoc (1). Fernand Braudel wrote The Mediterranean (3).

Code (C) gives these, and the other codes assign the books to the wrong authors.

Please log in or register to report this question.

76.

The "Idea of Progress" in historiography relates to

Exam Year(s)

UGC NET - 2013,

Answer: B

The idea of progress in historiography relates to the Enlightenment.

Enlightenment thinkers held that human society advances through reason and knowledge, which gave historians the idea of progress as a theme.

Romanticism stressed the particular and the past, postmodernism doubts grand narratives, and dialectical materialism is the Marxist method. The belief that mankind moves steadily to better conditions through reason is a theme of the eighteenth century, found in writers such as Condorcet and Voltaire, who wrote history as a story of the progress of the human mind.

Please log in or register to report this question.

77.

Match the List - I with List - II and select the correct answer from the codes given below :

List - IList - II
a. Collins, Larry and Lapierre1. Satanic Verses
b. Judith Brown2. The Great Divide : Britain-India-Pakistan
c. Salman Rushdie3. Freedom At Midnight
d. H.V. Hudson4. Gandhi's Rise to Power

Codes : a b c d

Exam Year(s)

UGC NET - 2013,

Answer: A

The correct pairing is a-3, b-4, c-1, d-2. Collins, Larry and Lapierre wrote Freedom at Midnight, Judith Brown wrote Gandhi's Rise to Power, Salman Rushdie wrote The Satanic Verses, and H.V. Hudson wrote The Great Divide: Britain-India-Pakistan.

The other code strings give the books to the wrong authors, for example the Satanic Verses to Collins and Lapierre, so they are wrong on at least one pair.

Please log in or register to report this question.

78.

Who has remarked, 'history is more interesting than a novel' ?

Exam Year(s)

UGC NET - 2013,

Answer: A

The remark that "history is more interesting than a novel" is credited to David Hume, the Scottish philosopher and historian, in the key. Hume wrote a History of England and held that history is a matter of interest and instruction.

Toynbee, Livy and Tacitus are historians, but the saying is not credited to any of them in the key, so they are wrong. Hume's views on history were part of the Enlightenment attitude that history can teach by example and give pleasure to the reader.

Please log in or register to report this question.

Answer: B

The statement that for a long time history was not considered a branch of literature is not correct. History was regarded as a branch of literature for a very long time, from ancient writers such as Herodotus, and the debate about its scientific character came later.

The other statements are correct: modern economic history rests on statistical data, creative ideas and their effect on society gave rise to intellectual history, and time and space give history its perspective.

Please log in or register to report this question.

80.

Who among the following declared that the postmodernist ideas were a menace to historical study ?

Exam Year(s)

UGC NET - 2013,

Answer: A

The person who declared that postmodernist ideas were a menace to historical study was Arthur Marwick, the British historian, who defended the claim of history to a body of reliable knowledge and attacked postmodernist doubts about it.

Holden Furber was a historian of the East India Company, Richard J. Evans defended history against postmodernism in his In Defence of History but is not the one credited in the key, and H.E. Barnes wrote on the history of historical writing.

Please log in or register to report this question.

Loading…

Other Subjects

Tags: Historical Method and Historiography Questions and Answers